Common HOA Fraud Schemes and Scams

Fraud in HOAs can take many forms, often exploiting weak oversight or internal controls. Below are some of the most prevalent schemes:

​

1. Embezzlement and Theft

• How it happens: A board member or property manager siphons funds through unauthorized withdrawals, forged checks, or falsified expense reports.

• Example: A Florida HOA treasurer embezzled $2 million over several years by writing unauthorized checks and manipulating financial records 2.

• Red flags:

  • Missing financial documents

  • Checks made out to "CASH" or board members personally 11

  • Unexplained drops in reserve funds

​

2. Vendor Kickbacks and Phantom Contracts

• How it happens: Board members steer contracts to vendors in exchange for bribes, gifts, or inflated invoices. Some even create fake vendors ("ghost vendors") to funnel money.

• Example: In a Nevada HOA, board members colluded with a landscaping company, inflating bids by $1.3 million and receiving kickbacks 6.

• Red flags:

  • Sudden price hikes without justification

  • Vendors with no verifiable business presence

  • Board members refusing competitive bidding

​

3. Election Rigging and Board Takeovers

• How it happens: Corrupt groups manipulate elections to install allies who then award contracts to themselves or associates.

• Example: The Las Vegas HOA scandal involved over 40 individuals rigging elections to control contracts, costing HOAs $58 million in fraudulent litigation deals 2.

• Red flags:

  • Restricted candidate nominations

  • Unusual voting irregularities

  • Rapid contract approvals after new board members take office

​

4. Selective Enforcement and Fake Fines

• How it happens: Board members impose arbitrary fines on certain homeowners while waiving penalties for friends or allies. Collected fines are then diverted for personal use.

• Example: A California HOA president collected $250,000 in fines, depositing them into a personal account disguised as a "community improvement fund" 2.

• Red flags:

  • Inconsistent rule enforcement

  • Fines without proper documentation

  • Funds not appearing in HOA financial statements

​

5. Reserve Fund Mismanagement

• How it happens: Boards misuse reserve funds for unauthorized projects, often without homeowner approval.

• Example: An Arizona HOA spent $1.2 million on a luxury clubhouse renovation while neglecting critical infrastructure repairs 2.

• Red flags:

  • Major expenditures without homeowner votes

  • Depleted reserves with no clear explanation

  • Poorly documented project approvals

​

How to Prevent Fraud in Your HOA

​

1. Implement Strong Financial Controls

• Require dual signatures on all checks and large transactions 

• Conduct monthly financial reconciliations, ensuring bank statements match bookkeeping records 

• Limit cash transactions—all payments should be traceable via check or electronic transfer 

​

2. Ensure Transparent Vendor Management

• Mandate competitive bidding for all major contracts 

• Disclose conflicts of interest—board members must recuse themselves if they have ties to a vendor

• Audit vendor invoices to verify services were actually rendered 

​

3. Conduct Regular Audits and Reviews

• Annual independent audits by a CPA can uncover discrepancies before they escalate

• Forensic audits may be necessary if fraud is suspected 

• Review payroll records to detect "phantom employees" (a scheme that cost one HOA $600,000)

​

4. Foster Community Oversight

• Publish financial reports online or in newsletters for homeowner review 

• Encourage meeting attendance—low participation allows fraud to thrive 

• Establish a whistleblower policy so residents can report suspicions anonymously 

​

5. Invest in Fraud Insurance

• Crime insurance covers losses from embezzlement, forgery, and social engineering scams 

• Fidelity bonds protect against theft by employees or board members 

• Directors & Officers (D&O) insurance shields the board from liability in fraud-related lawsuits 

​

What to Do If Fraud Is Suspected

1. Gather evidence (bank statements, invoices, meeting minutes) 

2. Call a special meeting to address concerns with the board 

3. Engage legal counsel and consider law enforcement if theft is confirmed 

4. File an insurance claim if covered under crime or fidelity policies 

​

Final Thoughts

Fraud in HOAs is not just a financial issue—it erodes trust and destabilizes communities. By implementing strict financial controls, ensuring transparency, and fostering active homeowner involvement, board members can significantly reduce the risk of fraud.

​

Key Takeaway: Prevention is always cheaper than recovery. A proactive approach saves your HOA from costly legal battles, special assessments, and reputational damage.